img
SarWatch Writer
Glencore and the Shutting Down of MUMI: blackmail or a real reaction to the challenges of the market?

The Swiss company Glencore has announced the imminent closure of Mutanda Mining (MUMI) in Lualaba Province of the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). The reason given by Glencore is that the Mutanda mine “is no longer economically viable in the long term” because of the decrease in the price of cobalt, the increase in the cost of certain inputs, and the “additional taxes now imposed by the mining code” as revised in 2018.

Glencore, the largest producer of copper and cobalt in the country, produces one-third of the world’s cobalt from its mines in the DRC. Shutting down the mine will have a negative impact on the national economy, on local communities, and on the mines’ employees (estimated to be more than 3 000 people).

Glencore’s alleged downward trend comes after a long period of improved cobalt prices on the international market. During this period, mining companies made excessive profits, often through illegal practices. They overvalued their operational costs and concealed their results behind fictitious debts in order to deprive the Congolese state of its right to levy taxes on these profits. On 12 June 2018, for instance, it took the threat of legal action before Glencore agreed to clear more than $5 billion of fictitious debt from another of its mines, the Kamoto Copper Company (KCC).

Having taken advantage of the market upturn to obtain undue and excessive benefits, Glencore’s decision to close the Mutanda mine has very little credibility, especially since the decline in the cobalt price was partly caused by the overproduction that resulted in companies (including Glencore) deliberately accumulating cobalt stocks. This deliberate stockpiling explains why prices remained low at a time when cobalt maintained its increasing strategic importance due to the demand of the electric vehicles industry. The operator who is responsible for the fluctuation in the price of cobalt is now complaining the most and threatening to shut down operations.

This is not Glencore’s first attempt to manipulate the market. In 2015, Glencore suspended the operations of its Kamoto Copper Company (KCC) mine for 18 months. The same duration is envisaged for the cessation of production at MUMI, and one can only wonder if this is mere coincidence. At the time, Glencore was accused of taking this step to avoid paying tax on profits to the Congolese state and profit shares to Gécamines. This decision was also made during the overproduction of copper on the international market. It therefore seems that we are facing a recurring behaviour that is part of Glencore’s well thought out strategy.

SARW believes that Glencore is using the decline in the price of colbalt to achieve two major goals: firstly, to force the new government (which is expected to be made public soon) to review the new mining code, which is something the company has sworn to achieve. The revision of the mining code was a tripartite negotiation, and the way parliament finally proceeded to adopt the final version of the law was not satisfactory to all the stakeholders. Despite the companies’ claims, the state has not yet taken any steps to reassure its private partners. However, the question is whether Glencore should be allowed to use this situation, which applies to all mining companies, to jeopardise the social conditions of its employees.

Secondly, just as in 2015, by closing the mine Glencore wants to avoid paying the high tax on cobalt, which is classified as a strategic mineral in the revised mining code, while anticipating that the price of cobalt will increase and that the new Congolese government can be pressurised to reduce the tax.

If the real objective of Glencore is to push the Congolese government to revise the mining code, their best attitude would be to wait for the new government to be established and then to start discussions that could lead to adjustments of the mining legislation. Such discussions should not be bilateral; they should include all the parties which were involved in the process of revision of the mining code that lasted from 2012 to 2018. Glencore’s tendency to exert pressure on the Congolese government looks like blackmail, and jeopardises the well-being of thousands of workers and their families. This should no longer be tolerated.

Glencore’s behaviour can only be tolerated in a country that has lost control over its mineral resources. It is time for the Congolese government to resume its role as actor and regulator of the extractive sector. For that, and considering that the tax regime of the mining legislation is declarative, the state must have a more efficient system for audit and control, a system that enables confirmation of the veracity of the basis of its private partners’ decisions. No company should be allowed to shut down if the analysis shows that it can easily recover losses. This is especially the case for Glencore, which not only produces cobalt, but also copper whose price is stable on the international market. Fluctuations in the prices of metals and their negative impact on companies have led some governments in Africa to introduce flexible and progressive tax regimes that allow companies to cover losses during price declines. In many cases governments have decided to lose on revenues in order to secure jobs.

Glencore’s growing monopoly on Congolese cobalt also poses another type of problem. During the third DRC Alternative Mining Indaba (AMI) organised by SARW in Kinshasa in July 2019, participants noted that some ores were declared “strategic” in order to benefit from improved prices of metals, while these minerals are not strategic per se. Glencore’s decision confirms AMI 2019 participants’ fears that the DRC, which does not control the fluctuation of metal prices on the international market and does not control production, cannot preserve the strategic nature of its cobalt. How can a mineral be “strategic” when one does not control its production, its flow, or its price on the market? The improvement in the price of minerals on the international market should not in future be used as the sole criterion for declaring a mineral as strategic. There is a need to think differently.

SARW recommends that the DRC government:

engages in direct discussions with Glencore with the aim fo conducting a rigorous audit of the motivations of Glencore’s decision – and if the reasons for that decision are unfounded, government should refute Glencore’s initiative and compel the company to develop a clear programme of reorganisation.

reforms state mining companies so that they become mining actors and operators capable of countering the manoeuvres of the multinationals that control the minerals.

protects the thousands of workers who are at risk of losing their jobs because of poor business planning by their employer who, after having benefited enormously from the rise in cobalt prices, now tries to blackmail the Congolese government.

Contact : PatriciaN@Sarwatch.org /nfo@sarwatch.org

img
PRESS RELEASE- CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANISATIONS WORKING ON EXTRACTIVE RESOURCE GOVERNANCE ON THE COPPERBELT PROVINCE OF ZAMBIA LAUNCH “THE COPPERBELT CIVIL SOCIETY MINING FORUM”

Ndola-Zambia – In response to the visible negative impact of mining activities on Copperbelt communities, ten national and regional advocacy organisations have come together to...

+ Read more
SARW’s RESPONSE TO THE CHAMBER OF MINES NAMIBIA MEDIA RELEASE OF 18 MARCH 2021

Re: Namibian Chamber of Mines observations on inaccuracies, faulty assumptions and allegations in the SARW Report. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND: This document serves as the official Southern...

+ Read more
Mining Workers’ Health Must be Prioritise before Profit

World Day for Safety and Health at Work 2021 28 April 2021

The COVID-19 global health crisis has exposed the lack of preparedness for disaster...

+ Read more
REPORT OF THE ACADEMIC SESSION TO THE ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COUNCIL

THE MINING CODE WITH REGARD TO THE IMPERATIVE OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Kinshasa, April 22, 2021

The Economic and Social Council (CES) was established...

+ Read more
RAPPORT DE LA SEANCE ACADEMIQUE AU CONSEIL ECONOMIQUE ET SOCIAL

LE CODE MINIER AU REGARD DE L’IMPERATIF DU DEVELOPPEMENT COMMUNAUTAIRE

Kinshasa, le 22 Avril 2021

Le Conseil Economique et Social (CES) a été...

+ Read more
SARW’s message on International World Health Day 2021

International World Health Day 2021 comes as the world continues to reflect on the impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic on people’s health. The occasion is...

+ Read more
How mineral resources can fuel the development of Africa in the context of post-Covid economic recovery

The UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs (DESA) has estimated that Covid-19 has pushed 131 million people into destitution in 2020. Its long-term effects...

+ Read more
SARW ANNUAL REPORT 2019

It  is with great pleasure the Southern Africa Resource Watch presents its first annual report as an independent watchdog that seeks to ensure that Africa, and...

+ Read more
SADC Countries Should Draw Lessons From Each Other’s Experiences to Harness the Extractive Industry for People’s Benefit

The drama of the U.S election, previously lauded as the beacon of democracy, has grabbed the world’s attention as the incumbent, President Trump, has refused...

+ Read more
SARW submission on Zambia’s mining legislation and policy framework

 SARW recently appeared before the legal review technical committee of the  Zambian Ministry of Mines and Minerals Development Act of 2015 (MMDA).  The...

+ Read more
Announcement on New Funding Support to SARW from the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation

We are pleased to share with you great news on the new funding support to SARW by The Charles Stewart Mott Foundation towards our Business...

+ Read more
ACCOMPAGNEMENT DE LA CHEFFERIE DE BAYEKE PAR SARW DANS LES CONSULTATIONS DES COMMUNAUTES EN VUE DE LA SIGNATURE DU CAHIER DES CHARGES DE L’ENTREPRISE TENKE FUNGURUME MINING

SARW est engagé dans un processus de renforcement des capacités des Entités Territoriales Décentralisées (ETD) en République Démocratique du Congo (RDC). C’est dans ce cadre...

+ Read more
Pursuing An Economic Independence Through the Control of Mineral Resources

Today we celebrate Africa Day at a time we are grappling with the health pandemic of COVID19. COVID 19 could reduce by more than half...

+ Read more
First Quantum Minerals and the New Science Lab at Kyafukuma School

Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARW) commends First Quantum Minerals (FQM) on the decision to support the community of Kyafukuma1 by providing support to the education...

+ Read more
Synthèse travaux société civile RDC

La Coordination des Actions des plaidoyers de la Société civile pour la gouvernance des Ressources naturelles s’est réunie, le jeudi 23 janvier 2020, dans la...

+ Read more
Civil Society Organisations Working Together for Change in Zimbabwe’s Extractive Industries

Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARW) hosted a roundtable discussion for civil society organisations working on the extractive industries in Zimbabwe, particularly the mining sector, on...

+ Read more
Revoke Lower Zambezi mine licence, demands Lange

THE Southern Africa Resource Watch has appealed for an advanced political intervention in the matter where a mining project is about to start in the...

+ Read more
Civil Society Africa Mining Vision Conference: Evaluation of the AMV Ten Years in Existence

As part of its resource diplomacy and capacity development programmes, the Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARW) in partnership with Third World Network (TWN), Tax Justice...

+ Read more
Colloquium on EITI Implementation in The Great Lakes Region

The Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARW) in partnership with ICGLR – Levy Mwanawasa Regional Centre for Democracy and Good Governance the technical and scientific organ...

+ Read more
Colloquium on EITI Implementation in The Great Lakes Region

The Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARW) in partnership with ICGLR – Levy Mwanawasa Regional Centre for Democracy and Good Governance the technical and scientific organ...

+ Read more
Glencore et La fermerture de MUMI : un chantage ou une réaction réelle aux défis du marché?

La compagnie Swisse Glencore a annoncé la fermeture imminente pour au moins deux ans de sa mine de Mutanda Mining (MUMI) dans la province de...

+ Read more
Official Statement on Silicosis and TB Class Action out of Court Settlement from Breathe Films and the Southern African Resource Watch

Breathe Films and the Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARW) welcome the judgement of The Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg, which has approved the historic...

+ Read more
Press Release in Parallel with the Third Edition Of The Alternative Mining Indaba/DRC

The 3rd edition of the Alternative Mining Indaba of the Democratic Republic of Congo (AMI/DRC) was held in Kinshasa, at the Pullman Hotel, from...

+ Read more
Clôture de la 3ème Alternative Mining Indaba sur fond d’un plaidoyer

Kinshasa12-07-2019Economie – Plusieurs recommandations ont été formulées au cours de cette 3ème Alternative Mining Indaba entre autres, s’assurer du contrôle des substances minières, vulgariser le...

+ Read more
A gift is a gift, says Glencore on $1.4bn DRC debt write-off — but US Dept of Justice is watching the mining giant

In July 2018 the US Department of Justice announced it was examining Glencore’s compliance with US laws on foreign corruption and money laundering. And in...

+ Read more
SARWatch and its partners visit First Quantum Minerals to assess its social corporate investment programme

SARWatch is undertaking a major investigation into the corporate social investment at Kansanshi Mine in Solwezi. Kansanshi Mine is subsidiary of First Quantum Minerals (FQM)....

+ Read more
Lualaba : L’ONG SARW s’oppose à la présence des militaires pour garder l’entreprise Tenke Fungurume mining

L’ONG Observatoire des ressources en Afrique australe (SARW) se dit préoccupée du déploiement des Forces armées de la RDC (FARDC) pour garder le...

+ Read more
SARWatch Participates in Publish What You Pay (PWYP) Global Assembly

“A real reflection of people’s movement, dedicated to changing the course of history.” – Ngoy Mango Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARWatch) participated in the 2019 Publish...

+ Read more
SARWatch and its Civil Society Partners Popularise the New Mining Code of the Democratic Republic of Congo

This new mining code continues to raise negative reactions from major mining companies regarding various concerns submitted to the head of state. On 9 March 2018,...

+ Read more